O'neal Lake

Description and Background

O’Neal Lake is a small shallow lake located in Northern Emmet County. It drains from Lawrence Lake and has one outlet, the headwaters of Big Sucker Creek. O’Neal Lake is approximately 145 acres in surface area. O’Neal Lake is part of the Lake Michigan watershed with the mouth of Big Sucker Creek flowing out into Lake Michigan. The land cover surrounding O’Neal Lake is predominantly forested wetland and some upland. The area surrounding O’Neal Lake is owned by the MDNR, State of Michigan and 8 parcels on the west side of the lake are owned by private owners, according to the 2003 Emmet County Plat Book. A dam built in 1952 is still present on O’Neal Lake. The lake has many dead inundated trees on the west side and has a heavy amount of aquatic vegetation throughout the lake, including wild rice planted by the LTBB NRD Inland Fisheries and Wildlife Programs.

The condition of the 1952 dam has been a point of contention since 2007.  The dam was in need of repairs and the main MDNR contact for managing O'Neal Lake, Wildlife Habitat Biologist Brian Mastenbrook, was contacted about the condition of the dam by riparian property owners. Mr. Mastenbrook wanted to implement a lake drawdown to breakdown the aquatic vegetation to release the nutrients within the plants, aerate the soil, and re-establish productivity in the substrate before a new dam was to be installed. The projected time to replenish the conditions of the substrate was estimated to be two to three years. The MDNR held a public meeting in early 2008, which resulted in clear opposition of this management technique by the local community. LTBB’s WQPP and Inland Fisheries and Wildlife Program (IFWP) have been collecting data on this lake for over 15 years. One of the concerns from the local community was what this management decision was based on. MDNR has indicated that scientific data was not used in this decision other than a couple observation site visits. LTBB decided to present all of the data collected in, near, and adjacent to this lake to the public at the O'Neal Lake Informational Meeting held on August 27th, 2009. Data indicated that loons and other avian species, geese, eagles and osprey all nest and feed on fish in the lake; there is a viable pan fishery, potential for wild rice growth, the lake is a cultural/ceremonial area for Tribal Citizens, water quality supports aquatic life and wildlife, and  native plant communities exist to feed wildlife and provide habitat. LTBB IFWP also does frequent flights for eagle research and was able to supply photos of areas already available to waterfowl throughout Wilderness State Park.  At this point in time, LTBB was only providing ecological information for the local community to understand O'Neal Lake diversity and functions. Later in this year, the LTBB Natural Resource Commission declared that O'Neal Lake was a viable fishery. There was a discussion to collaborate with the MDNR to create and implement a lake management plan but this did come into fruition. There was some minimal work done to minimize leakage and some additional boards were added to the top of the dam. In the fall of 2014, the dam unexpectedly failed, allowing for the lake to drawdown and drain into Big Sucker Creek. Engineers contracted with the MNDR have completed their draft engineering report with three different solutions and these solutions were presented at the first of many meetings that will take place in effort to come up with a solution to this problem. The engineering report is still in draft phase and has not been released to the public. LTBB will be an active participant in these meetings. The LTBB NRD staff and Director will be part of the solution, particularly with a financial contribution depending on what the final solution is. The data summary table and narrative summary will indicate if there have been changes to the water chemistry or parameters taken in the fall following the drawdown compared to the spring, summer and previous year's datasets. It is important to note that change in water quality parameters may not be present immediately after or during this drawdown. The WQPP recommendation would be to review all data taken from LTBB NRD to include wildlife and fish data to present it with a whole ecosystem approach. To view a map of the lake and the WQPP monitoring location please reference Map 6 in the Appendix. 

Tribal Uses and Attainment

The primary Tribal use on O'Neal Lake (OLL) was WF. Oher Tribal uses applied are IAW, WRA and PSC (potential of cercarial dermatitis to occur in this lake). These uses will need further evaluation and support is dependent on the managed use and future outcome of the lake. Since only one set of data was taken during this reporting period after the dam failure, analysis of post dam failure data will need to be analyzed in the next reporting period. Future monitoring will occur in the winter of 2015 and seasonally in 2016. If a solution to the dam failure is not sought by the winter of 2016, the WQPP may increase sampling from seasonal to monthly through May-October in 2016 for a larger data set to be collected. 


LEGEND


DO Dissolved Oxygen
Respiration for fish, other aquatic organisms

TEMP Temperature
General aquatic life support and reproduction

COND Conductivity
General aquatic life support, dissolved solids indicator

CHLOR Chlorides
General life support, salinity indicator, drinking water pollutant

PH Potential Hydrogen Ion Concentration 
Acidity/alkalinity indicator, drinking water pollutant

TP Total Phosphorous
Major algae nutrient, fertilizer/manure runoff indicator

TN Total Nitrogen
Major algae nutrient, drinking water pollutant, fertilizer/manure runoff indicator

CHL-A Chlorophyll-a 
Algae concentration indicator

HAB Habitat
Instream and riparian structure to support life cycles of fish and other organisms

MAC Macroinvertebrates
Indicator of water quality based on the diversity of pollution tolerant and intolerant
aquatic insects and non-insects that are visible to the naked eye and do not have a backbone

TSS Total Suspended Solids 
Indicator of aquatic life support, oxygen levels

FQA Floristic Quality Assessments
Indicates quality of wetland based on the plant community present 
 

CONDITION INDICATORS


Poor    Fair   Good   Very Good